Finda: Sunshine Coast

Features

Aussie Muslims support Sharia law: Trad

8th March 2010

flickr.com/Ranoush.

THERE'S broad Muslim community support for aspects of Sharia law being adopted in Australia, a leading spokesman for the religion says.

However, harsh penal aspects of the law, including stoning and chopping off hands, will never work and aren't being called for, Islamic Friendship Association of Australia president Keysar Trad says.

But personal aspects of the law, particularly those involving marriage and inheritance, would be broadly supported and would offer great help to ordinary Australian Muslims, he said.

Mr Trad's remarks come after Dr Zachariah Matthews, president of the Australian Islamic Mission, made a similar call, saying aspects of Sharia law could run parallel to existing legislation.

Dr Matthews was speaking during an open day at Lakemba Mosque in Sydney on Saturday.

Some non-Muslims in the audience were reportedly left shocked by the speech.

"Most people seem to think that when it comes to Sharia law it's just about the penal provisions, but that's not that case," Mr Trad told AAP on Monday.

"(The penal provisions) can't work here. No serious person would advocate them."

But he said adopting aspects of Sharia marital and inheritance law - in a dual legal system - would be an advantage, particularly for women.

"At the moment it can disadvantage Muslims here, particularly women, because if a woman gets divorced through the normal civil process that divorce is not recognised in Muslim countries," Mr Trad said.

"So they would still be considered to be married elsewhere."

Equally, Australian governments don't recognise divorce documents made by imams, the mosque and community leaders, Mr Trad said.

"These are all considerations that Muslims living in Australia face all the time and a lot of them support introducing these parts of Sharia law here," he added.

Dr Matthews also said he was not proposing the introduction of wider Sharia law.

"I don't think we are so unsophisticated that we cannot consider a multi-layered legal system as long as it doesn't conflict with the existing civil system," he was quoted as saying by Fairfax.

There are about 340,000 Muslims in Australia, or 1.7 per cent of the population, Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show.

© AAP

Join the Discussion!

Comments (0) | Add Your Comments

Recent comments on this article

   

Are you kidding? Are they doing this in the US? The Catholic church doesn't believe in divorce either, are they coming out with a law to run parallel with the legal system? Please don't be like the US conforming in an attempt to make everyone happy and putting aside Australian culture and belief. I have no problem with anyone practicing their own beliefs, but don't try to shove your beliefs on me, just as I don't try to push them on you.

By Justice on 8/3/2010 at 6:45PM Suggest removal
   

Come and live in this awesome country accept our laws and way of life. If you dont like it leave! If you convert to this religion you still have the laws of our country to live by! I will not abide by any Muslim law as this is Australia and its a christian country if you look at the constitution!

By helens on 8/3/2010 at 9:45PM Suggest removal
   

Anyone watch V on Sunday .. the Visitors ..

Hey, its begun already...

Islam is all about domination by stealth, one little step at a time.

Whoa .. hold the phone a second. Of course we practice and accept religious freedom in this country and so we always should and must.

We need to respect each others belief systems.

But, what do we do when those belief systems start to clash at some very fundamental levels with our "current" set of values.

What would we like to see happen?

Should we marginalise our beliefs and our values for those of another religion for the sake of religious tolerance?

A delicate subject, best handled by common sense on both sides and a lot of education and information flowing between all sides. Tread gently and with respect for each other.

By ThePeanutGallery on 8/3/2010 at 10:12PM Suggest removal
   

When people from anywhere come to Australia to live, they have to accept our laws and our way of life. If they are not happy with this, they should go back to where they came from. Australia, and I, welcome people from various countries and religions, but they do need to embrace our way of life.

By Gotta-B-Jokin on 9/3/2010 at 6:19AM Suggest removal
   

There is only one law in Australia - Australian Law. If you can't live under it then leave. This (if past) would be the thin edge of the wedge. What next? Exclusive Brethen law, Aboriginal Law, Catholic Law , you get the drift. People who propose these things are only trouble makers with hidden agendas.

By TSMBBS on 9/3/2010 at 6:27AM Suggest removal
   

If Muslims living in Australia you don't like Australian laws as they are, the solution is obvious.

By Southsider on 9/3/2010 at 6:18AM Suggest removal
   

We dont want or need Sharia law here and we should strongly opose it. This is Australia. Its not a muslim country. If the muslims want sharia law best they go to a muslim country. If they dont like the way we do things here they shoud get back to the existance they came here from. GET OUT.

By JohnS on 9/3/2010 at 6:16AM Suggest removal
   

Assimilate or migrate elsewhere. I don't see Aussies going abroad telling people that they need to have sausage sizzles every weekend. When in Rome.

By swainy67 on 9/3/2010 at 7:18AM Suggest removal
   

I believe there are some countries in the world who
have Sharia Law as their only system.
Go and live there!

By eclipse on 9/3/2010 at 7:58AM Suggest removal
   

@helens of Buderim,

I'm sorry, I'm having difficulty finding the part of the Constitution that refers to Austalia being a Christian country. Maybe you were mistaken.

By blah2 on 9/3/2010 at 8:20AM Suggest removal
   

as theses people who once were a minority now become a majority of course thay would want to change the laws to better suit them.
but this is australia and these people have come over here to escape the problems in their own country but in doing so thay bring their problems with them and as they have come to australia that have to abide buy our laws and no we should not change our laws or our customs to apease these people as in there eyes non muslims do not matter

By greg1010 on 9/3/2010 at 8:21AM Suggest removal
   

@swain67

no, we just invade them if they don't agree with our principles, ie. Vietnam, Iraq.

By blah2 on 9/3/2010 at 8:58AM Suggest removal
   

If people come to live in Australia they need to adhere to australian laws. There is no room for laws from other countries to be used here as well. After all Muslim countries don't have Australian laws running alongside theirs either & would agree there is no place for such a system there.

By Browneyes on 9/3/2010 at 8:20AM Suggest removal
   

How simple and primitive that so many people in the world still believe in all this religious and belief rubbish. We’re still living in the stone age and really haven’t progressed very far at all. Its no wonder there’s so much conflict in the world.

Labelling people with different beliefs like products in a supermarket. We may be educated animals but really we still know nothing. We are the only species that actually lacks the intelligence to see the truth.

People have designed beliefs and religions to help them cope with their simple lives and then use it as a means to an end to actually think they’ll be better off in life if they follow those rulings.

I’m sure there are still some intelligent people out there that must realize this way of life no longer works in a modern society.

We are all one peoples and we don’t need religious beliefs to hide behind any longer.

By picman2 on 9/3/2010 at 9:42AM Suggest removal
   

Is this any different than catholic.

Apparently the church only recognize catholic nuptials and doesn't recognize civil divorces.

By DDronning on 9/3/2010 at 10:16AM Suggest removal
   

If people accept our hospitality and come to live in this country then they accept our way of life ... simple as that ... if I go to a muslim country I accept that I must conform to their laws and culture ... religion is the basis of 90% of this world's problems ... hypocrites ...

By ceebails on 9/3/2010 at 10:32AM Suggest removal
   

Inch by Inch.... Step by Step......

In every country overseas where this has happened, when the Muslim laws have been banned, there comes violence. I honestly believe we are not dealing with a religion that intends to live comfortably side by side with ANY other religion. Why, even in their own country where different aspects of the religion exist, they murder and maim at a whim. In fact, Sharia Law is often the means and excuse by which differing sects are murdered and these attrocities are accepted BECAUSE they are Sharia Law and thereby "sanctioned" by God... or in this case, Allah.

Are we so stupid as to accept this within Australia's borders? Probably.....

By Esbee on 9/3/2010 at 10:39AM Suggest removal
   

You cannot run two legal systems side by side;
Muslims left their homelands to either get away from the regimes who imposed Sharia Law or for the better life style ( there is a more contoversial reason but for now I leave that alone ). When Australians travel to or live in Muslim countries we have to abide by local law, but when do they allow foreigners to change their law or allow us to change ther society. As many have said, IF Muslims want Sharia Law, then it is best for all, that they return to their homeland immediately, where they can enjoy their Sharia Law.

By theanalyst101 on 9/3/2010 at 11:24AM Suggest removal
   

The last line in of the Australian Citizenship Pledge is "whose laws I will uphold and obey." It doesn't say anything about other laws. What will the Aussie Muslims want to change or add to next?

By Dacey41 on 9/3/2010 at 11:48AM Suggest removal
   

It is very simple. Australia is a Christian country, it was founded on Christian beliefs and principles. In the event that any system of beliefs do not agree with the law of the land based on these Christian principles then you have my permission to leave and go to a country that supports your beliefs. Do not expect others to accept, adopt or conform in any way shape or form to laws based on an alien belief system.

Fedup

By Fedup on 9/3/2010 at 12:54PM Suggest removal
   

A number of Muslim women in Australia find aspects of their religion oppressive and seek to liberate themselves from it. Coming to Australia is their first step towards more freedom from their religion.
In the UK females are routinely murdered for this.
We would profoundly let them down if we talk nonsense such as considering aspects of Sharia law. We are seeing Muslim men trying to stifle the only avenue of freedom their women are seeking in Australia.

By Bellows on 9/3/2010 at 12:47PM Suggest removal
   

All you have to do is see what happened in Europe and decide whether this is what we want, I don't think so and for the sake of upsetting a few of the minority or squeaky wheels then I think it's worth preserving our laws and lifestyles and not bowing to more and more to keep a particular group happy. If you like our milk and honey then do your bit to assimilate to "Our" culture.

By swainy67 on 9/3/2010 at 12:44PM Suggest removal

Top Picks

Sunshine Coast

  1. /

  2. /

  3. /

  4. /

Local News

Emergency service workers deal with the aftermath of yesterday morning’s fatal collision on Noosa Cooroy Road. Teen dies in high speed crash

THREE hundred metres of road and 24 hours were all that stood between the fight of a lifetime for one Tewantin teen and the tragic end of another yesterday.

Things To Do

Ads by Google