Finda: Sunshine Coast

Features

'Die with dignity' in Coffs

Graeme Singleton 10th February 2010

Coffs Harbour Historic Cemetery.

Coffs Harbour Historic Cemetery.

Coffs Coast Advocate

IT is a great place to live and a great place to visit – but Coffs Harbour is also now a great place to die.

That’s according to one of Australia’s foremost authorities on ageing, Professor Colleen Cartwright.

“It’s probably not something you would want to put on tourist brochures but I find it very gratifying that Coffs Harbour really is one of the best places to end your life with dignity,” Prof Cartwright said.

“And that’s all due to the ageing culture we have developed here,” she said.

The internationally recognised academic is based at the local campus of Southern Cross University where she heads the Aged Services Learning and Research Centre.

While Prof Cartwright has long been involved in issues surrounding frail older people living in the community and in aged care, she said she has increasingly become engaged in the debate about dying. She particularly welcomed the intellectual and emotional stimulus provided by Monday night’s ABC 4 Corners program about palliative care.

“We need to have an open debate about dying, and about the dignity of dying,” Prof Cartwright said.

“And we need to distinguish between what is and isn’t euthanasia. People get confused but in my mind prolonging a life full of pain is little more than abuse. We need to understand that sometimes medical intervention merely prolongs death rather than prolongs life.”

In the 4 Corners program, the director of the Sacred Heart Palliative Care Unit in Sydney, Dr Richard Chye, argued that the medical community’s obsession with curing sickness is leaving some terminally ill patients poorly cared for and unprepared for death.

As well Prof Ken Hillman, from the University of NSW, said too many very ill patients end up in acute-care hospital wards when, in fact, they would be better off in other settings to die peacefully.

“We want to look after them. We want to cure them. And in doing so we’ve set up a situation where it’s difficult to die peacefully,” Prof Hillman said.

Prof Cartwright said giving people the option of dying ‘on their own terms’ was at the core of initiatives developed in Coffs Harbour over the past decade that had made the city a better place to pass over.

“In our residential aged care system people now don’t have to go to hospitals to die,” Prof Cartwright said. “They can be left to die in their familiar environment rather than in the acute care ward of a hospital. It is a much more dignified option.”

Prof Cartwright said the obsession of some doctors to unnecessarily prolong life inevitably left many carers angry and bitter.

“All they can do is interrupt the dying path. All they do is put obstacles in place but they can only delay not defy the process of dying. Stopping or removing futile treatments is not euthanasia. It is humane.”

Professor Cartwright said people needed to know that in Australia people have a legal right to refuse food and medication, and the ability to make out Advance Health Care Directives which detail their dying wishes.

Coffs Coast Advocate  

Join the Discussion!

Comments (1) | Add Your Comments

Recent comments on this article

   

This is such a never-ending debate that will really go nowhere and it seems these supposed scholars perhaps make a living by going around stirring up these issues. Yes I’m sure we all agree we’re going to die and how we die should be our choice.

But the problem is I don’t think any government in Australia will say okay here’s a suicide pill to make your final days quicker and less painless. And if it ever did the system would be open to massive abuse opening up legal nightmares.

Any form of medical intervention does in most cases prolong life that’s why millions of people take daily medication and get life saving treatment. If this would all stop tomorrow people would be dying just like they were hundred years ago. But we have supposedly advanced in society and technology.

Perhaps in another hundred years people may be kept alive another 50 years who knows? I suppose if people want to kill themselves it could be made easier but who decides when the person themselves cant anymore. A judge, a doctor, a relative and what if they’re wrong? Who will be the executioner?

Will it get to the stage when doctors say there’s no more room for anymore in this place some will have to go lets choose? This is already happening in our medical system.

Many doctors are already choosing not to prolong people’s lives as they have done for years and are still doing everyday. This is no secret. The hospital system can’t cope with patient quantities and nor can outside care options.

Many carers just simply can’t cope with the care of their family members and the government shouldn’t be placing carers in this position. When it gets to the stage when a carer can no longer cope its no wonder they want a quick way out. But that’s not to say that relative may not live for some years longer. Older people will always be a burden on others.

But I suppose we are still human beings to some and expecting relatives to cope with the aged and frail is definitely no answer at all. Proving a death pill to people to solve the doctors over stocking problem is a quick fix for them no doubt. Is it ethical? It was for Adolf Hitler.

Animals are put down everyday and I expect this may end up being the future for some of us.

By picman2 on 10/2/2010 at 6:10AM Suggest removal

Top Picks

Sunshine Coast

  1. /

  2. /

  3. /

  4. /

Local News

Daniel Watson almost lost his arm because of shortage of hospital beds. Bed shortage almost 'cost an arm'

A MINYAMA father has called for the Sunshine Coast's new hospital to be built faster, amid claims a bed shortage almost cost his son an arm.

  • Noosa Jazz Festival
    Saturday, 4 Sep, 2010 – 9am
    Noosa Heads
    The Noosa Jazz Festival will be offering a stellar line up that will be all genre of jazz music from the traditional to the more modern funk and blues. View details
  • Healthy Ageing and Lifestyle Expo
    Saturday, 4 Sep, 2010 – 9am
    Maroochydore
    The expo specifically designed to increase awareness of health, wellness and lifestyle options through an offering of over 100 presentations and exhibit. View details
  • Noosa Country Show
    Friday, 10 Sep, 2010 – 9am
    Pomona
    The Noosa Country Show is set to be bigger, brighter and better than ever before. View details
  • Over the Fence Comedy Film Festival
    Friday, 10 Sep, 2010 – 7pm
    Nambour
    Eleven films make up this years short film event. View details
  • Noosa Biosphere Day
    Sunday, 19 Sep, 2010 – 10am
    Noosa Heads
    A free community event to celebrate the 'birthday' of the Noosa Biosphere designation in 2007. View details

      Ads by Google